Analyzing the Social Context of Health Information and Misinformation during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Case of Emerging Inequities in Lebanon

American University of Beirut
"The differences in the public's experiences with and the use of the communicated messages during this pandemic point to the need to acknowledge variations in the types of societies, and to understand the inherent nature of their social networks and the social relations among their members in order to improve the messages to suit their needs..."
Grounded in behavioural and social science theory, research, and practice, risk communication in public health aims at promoting healthy behaviours among individuals and communities through strategic exchange of information. However, the concomitant spread of misinformation related to public health emergencies has become more prominent and rapid with the global proliferation of social media, resulting - in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic - in what the World Health Organization (WHO) has termed an "infodemic". This paper refers to social science and risk communication theory to discuss how the political, economic, and social contexts in a country, and not only the content of the messages that people receive from officials, affect how they interpret and act on information. It highlights how this has played out in Lebanon, whose government declared a "state of general mobilization" on March 15 2020 after reporting its first confirmed case on February 21 2020. It also identifies societal aspects of importance in a low- and middle-income country (LMIC) fraught with social, economic, and political inequalities that undermine efforts to contain the spread of COVID-19. Implications to inform state response in the context of other LMICs are also discussed.
As reported here, the Lebanese government's message-centred approach to health communication relies largely on a uni-directional and didactic provision of information that addresses self-protection measures and the importance of flattening the curve. (This is reflective of a "realist approach" to risk communication.) Citizens have been asked to abide by strict public health measures of nighttime curfews and vehicle movement rotation, but the Lebanese state has been struggling to reach and maintain public adherence to these measures, especially in view of the gradual ease of the lockdown that started in May 2020.
In contrast to such a limited understanding, this paper adopts a social and behavioural science lens to examine the various factors in the Lebanese context that affect people's actions or inactions in the face of the COVID-19 pandemic. "These same factors play a decisive role in the course of this pandemic in similar multicultural settings around the globe." Specifically, in Lebanon, the population's access to, interpretation of, and action on information are affected by:
- The collectivist nature of society: "Lebanese society is predominantly a strong kinship culture, which resonates with many multicultural settings around the globe and is in contrast to individualist cultures." This social setting has influenced the spread of both harmful and beneficial behaviours during the pandemic. For example, "personal space is minimal, and those who refrain from interacting with people in a collective space are frowned upon. This has a bearing on the physical distancing recommendation, which is difficult to understand and to apply in Lebanon because this concept is alien to this culture."
- A history of state failures: "The collapse of the Lebanese state in various periods of modern history, such as during the Lebanese Civil War (1975-90), has created a vacuum which warlords filled. They have ruled the country since 1990, creating instead of a trustworthy egalitarian system, an unequal system...[The] disaggregate approach to handling the outbreak in the country has further diminished the role of the state....Delayed risk communication and contradictory messages and their enactment by the Lebanese government officials affected people’s trust." The result has been evidence of belief in conspiracy theories, disbelief by some that the pandemic is real, and - ultimately - lack of adherence to messages of self-protection.
- The dire socioeconomic conditions of the country: In Lebanon, an already catastrophic economic situation has been made worse by nationwide coronavirus lockdowns. Disadvantage and marginalisation are widespread, with groups such as Syrian, Palestinian, and Iraqi refugees, migrant workers, and incarcerated individuals experiencing multiple social inequalities - including lack of information - amidst the absence of equitable social protection schemes that make them more vulnerable to COVID-19.
- "A stark general mistrust in the national health system."
This analysis illustrates the need for risk communication to attend to the context within which information travels and is used, including the social, economic, and political conditions that impact the people's implementation of recommended strategies. Rather than putting forth simplified messages demanding specific changes in people's behaviour, communicators must ask questions such as, "How would refraining from engaging in routine interactions for lengthy periods of time be interpreted by close-knit extended families in rural areas?" Asking such questions enables us to understand, for example, that:
- Existing social structures, social institutions, and key individuals could be leveraged to mobilise communities and work out contextually acceptable alternatives to physical distancing and crowding.
- The state could design a communication and implementation strategy to build trust and prevent the spread of misinformation by providing clear, consistent messages and to being transparent about what health and other officials know and do not know.
- The state could work to provide social and health protection schemes for all its population, particularly for disadvantaged populations and the incarcerated, to mitigate economic vulnerabilities and enable adherence to virus prevention measures.
In conclusion: "The analysis of the experience in Lebanon is relevant to public health responses in similar contexts around the globe. With increased global connectedness, societies are in constant change and portray various forms of internal diversity; thus lessons learned from such experiences can inform stakeholders in designing future health communication for similar responses."
Global Health Promotion 1757-9759; Vol 0(0): 1-9; 984178. Image credit: Wikimedia Commons











































