"On Whose Side Are You?": Artist-Researcher Positionality in a Global Public Health Challenge

Tampere University
This paper introduces an artistic research project drawing on interviews with vaccine-critical parents and a vaccine scientist about their opposing standpoints toward immunisation and vaccination. The project was undertaken in the context of an increase in vaccine hesitancy, particularly in developed countries, with the resultant outbreaks of previously eradicated infectious diseases. Artist-researcher Kaisu Koski observes that, primarily concerning children's health, the issue is emotionally sensitive and difficult to explore without taking sides, given the current polarised pro- and anti-camps. In the paper, she considers the risks she faced in mediating a dialogue in which those with clashing worldviews may both hope for her advocacy of their respective viewpoints, expecting her to side with them.
Koski makes the point that, in essence, both the pro- and the anti-vaccine groups share the same fundamental goal. Both groups even use similar strategies of power in their communication, claiming to possess real knowledge and to be more trustworthy. Setting the differences aside, most participants in the debate are focused on achieving a better state of health. For the pro-vaccine side, the main threats to attaining this goal are illness and death, whereas for the anti-vaccine side, the main danger is a disturbed course of nature.
The vaccine hesitancy project discussed here was conducted within the larger framework of "Immune Nations" (2015-2020), a group of international artists, scientists, and policymakers invited to collaboratively explore issues related to immunisation. For the research procedure, Koski first interviewed vaccine-critical parents in the Netherlands and Finland, aiming to capture the health beliefs that formed the background of their vaccine criticism. Next, she discussed these beliefs with senior scientist Johan Holst from the Norwegian Institute of Public Health, whose views were in contrast with the parents' views (and her own). Both the parents' interviews and the artist-scientist dialogue are featured in a short documentary entitled Conversations with vaccine-critical parents (2017: view trailer). See Related Summaries, below, for additional publications on how this documentary has been used as part of an educational intervention for medical students.
Koski provides background on the concept of risk in artistic research from the standpoint of institutional ethics protocols, focusing on situations where an artist-researcher involves human participants and collaborators from different contexts and disciplines. Traditionally, institutional research ethics guidelines have not addressed art's particular relationships with risk. One question is how and what to communicate to prospective participants, in the absence of the (yet-to-be-created) artwork, when recruiting them and requesting their informed consent.
Several risks also emerge from the controversial topic of vaccine hesitancy in particular, including: "1) risk of misrepresenting either the parents' or the scientist's views; 2) risk of promoting vaccine hesitancy by making the vaccine-critical parents exotic and romanticizing the 'purity' of their lifestyle; 3) risk of promoting vaccines, with the project being used to limit their voluntariness, eventually setting up the participants for an even more difficult situation; 4) risk of drawing an artificially solid border between pro- and anti-vaccine views, while several aspects of it may be blurred (about behavior but especially on the level of ideas); and 5) the lack of a single-sided opinion and agenda, which may leave the artist-researcher vulnerable to psychological manipulation by the participants."
Koski discusses positionality - the notion that personal values, views, and location in time and space influence how a researcher understands the world - regarding vaccine hesitancy. She explains that she openly communicated to the participants and the collaborator her own somewhat hesitant attitude toward vaccines, and that her primary intention in this project was to expand medical students' horizon of how to respectfully communicate with vaccine-critical parents. Yet misunderstandings may arise from showing only selected parts of the discussions in the documentary film. When she was with the parents, for instance, her tone of voice was primarily sympathetic. However, she later tried to present their views to Johan the scientist in a neutral manner. Since only the latter segments are included in the film, where the parents' answers are narrated in Koski's "neutral" or detached voice, the parents may perceive a dissonance between her presence in the interviews and the film.
There are power relations between the artist-researcher, participants, and collaborator to be explored; "in the case of a film-based study," Koski explains, "this is manifested through the process of editing in particular. As the creator of this film, I eventually decide which voices and images should be included and even have the possibility to re-record my own voice in case I would be dissatisfied with my spontaneous formulations. The participants and the collaborators typically lack access to this process."
In reflecting on the entire experience and the themes discussed in this paper, Koski notes that, when thanking the parents after showing them a preview of the rough cut of my film, one parent responded, "On whose side are you?" This comment implies that either she gave the parents the impression (at some point) that she would be on their side, or it seems that, in the film, she is taking Johan's side. She concludes: "Even though I feel uneasy for upsetting any participant of the project, it is difficult to think that I could have proceeded significantly differently in the filmmaking process."
The film has thus far been employed in 2 medical schools' curriculum, and the students’ responses have been studied through qualitative analysis (again, see Related Summaries, below). In addition, the film reaches out to a variety of different scientific and artistic contexts internationally. These include invited screenings at an epidemiologists' training event, multiple curated expositions, film festival selections, and medical educational conference presentations.
Click here to read the paper online.
Click here in order to download the paper in PDF format (11 pages).
VIS - Nordic Journal for Artistic Research 2019 1(1).











































