Vaccine Refusal - What We Need to Know

Universidade Federal de São Paulo (UNIFESP), Escola Paulista de Medicina, Departamento de Pediatria; and Faculdade São Leopoldo Mandic
"It is important to consider that most parents trust the information offered by pediatricians and, although they might have some questions, they will follow the healthcare professional's advice, including on vaccination."
Despite efforts to ensure the distribution and application of vaccines, aiming at individual and collective benefits, people and groups who have concerns about the safety and need for vaccine application are present worldwide. The purpose of this review is to educate healthcare professionals about vaccine hesitancy and refusal, as well as its causes and consequences, and to make suggestions to address this challenge.
A look at the National Immunization Program (Programa Nacional de Imunização [PNI]) indicates that, although vaccine coverage of more than 90% for almost all the immunobiological agents has been achieved in that country, in 2016, in the states of Pernambuco and Ceará, after a decrease in immunisation rates, the country recorded the first measles outbreak since 2000; moreover, the polio immunisation rate in 2016 was the lowest of the last 12 years (84.4%) in Brazil. Although it is not yet possible to define whether this is a temporary vaccination coverage oscillation or if there is an actual decrease, these data are of concern.
As the author explains, vaccine acceptance is the final result of a decision-making process influenced by several factors. For the World Health Organization (WHO)'s SAGE Working Group on Vaccine Hesitancy has articulated, the determinants of this behaviour can be characterised by the 3Cs model: Confidence (trust in healthcare professionals, vaccines, and their effectiveness), Complacency (low awareness of the risks of vaccine-preventable diseases and the importance of vaccines), and Convenience (availability of and accessibility to vaccines and healthcare services). Thus, vaccine refusal cannot be defined as a dichotomous behaviour of acceptance versus refusal, but rather as a continuum between the two, with individuals who refuse all vaccines at one end, those who accept all vaccines at the other, and those who accept some but refuse others in between.
The determinants of vaccine refusal/hesitancy are complex and can be attributed to the confluence of several sociocultural, political, and personal factors, which are examined in the article. For example, access to information (and misinformation) on vaccines released by the media influences decision-making; parents with insufficient knowledge about vaccine-preventable diseases (VPDs) may show negative attitudes toward vaccines and healthcare professionals. In this context, paediatricians in particular, who maintain direct and frequent contact with parents, play a key role in maintaining vaccine confidence and are considered the main and most reliable source of information for patients. A review of 185 articles on vaccination hesitancy among health professionals carried out in 2016 showed that knowledge about vaccines and their efficacy and safety increased the professionals' confidence and the prescription of these immunobiological agents; most articles revealed that an appropriately vaccinated professional is more likely to prescribe vaccines, which makes more evident the need for continuing education and training.
The literature suggests that communication with parents and caregivers about child vaccination is one way to address vaccine refusal; such communication must be a two-way process (from professional to the caregiver and vice versa), supporting vaccination in a creative and ethical way. In addition to discussing vaccines (their benefits and challenges) and the diseases that can be prevented by vaccination, it is necessary to provide information about vaccination sites available; moreover, the healthcare professional must welcome the experiences, fears, and beliefs that parents and caregivers have on vaccines to adequately assess what kind of communication should be established to guide the decision to vaccinate. It is necessary to consider that currently, in addition to the recommendations provided by healthcare professionals, the search for information about vaccines among friends and on the internet (on Twitter, Facebook, Google, and YouTube, among others) is the rule, allowing a rapid gathering of information outside the scientific environment, thus increasing the chance of spreading information of questionable quality.
Preparing medical students and residents to identify and treat VPDs is an important tool to prepare them to provide guidance on the importance of vaccines for the control of such diseases. However, there has been little research on the teaching of vaccines in medical schools and their consequences on vaccine confidence. Guides for the health care professional to face the problem are emerging. The WHO, the United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), and various medical associations have issued technical guidelines and manuals that present the causes, reinforce the consequences, and suggest strategies for coping with vaccine hesitancy or refusal, including establishing principles for health professionals to provide answers when confronted in public with anti-vaccine groups. In Brazil, the Brazilian Society of Pediatrics (Sociedade Brasileira de Pediatria [SBP]) and the Federal Council of Medicine (Conselho Federal de Medicina [CFM]), concerned about the advent of the anti-vaccination movement, issued an alert on June 23 2017 urging the population, physicians, and other healthcare professionals to counteract said movement. It is noted that ethical and legal discussions should be part of clinical practice, which helps physicians in their decision-making and in the recommendations provided to parents.
Concluding thoughts include: "Discussing aspects of the vaccines at each pediatric visit is an excellent starting point. It is necessary to provide the information and ensure that it has been correctly understood; hearing and accepting doubts without judging their relevance. Discussing the benefits of vaccines, keeping an open mind to relay knowledge, and accepting cultural and intellectual differences are very important....It is important to suggest to parents that having access to safe information from healthcare professionals, the Ministry of Health, and medical societies is preferable to information from sources whose safety and credibility are debatable. Taking every opportunity to talk about vaccines, not just to the child, but to other family members, can have a significant impact, particularly when mothers are pregnant again."
Jornal de Pediatria, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jped.2018.01.008. Image credit: Health Impact News











































